Accent on Natural Landscaping

Donna VanBuecken

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Resources
  • Organizations & Blogs
  • Archives
  • Contact

Unintended Consequences of Rural Buffer Zones

August 8, 2016

Bee on New England Asters (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae; formerly Aster novae-angliae).
New England Asters (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae; formerly Aster novae-angliae), a favorite pollinator plant, is often found growing in cropland buffer zones.

We’ve thought for some time overspray and drift into rural buffer zones from insecticide treated crops affects insects, but now there is proof. A scientific study conducted in Brookings, South Dakota has concluded the strips of rural habitat being grown near cropland have unintentionally negatively affected honey bee health. Christina Mogren and Jonathan Lundgren recently published their findings indicating pollinator plantings near neonicotinoid-treated seed cropland result in an unintentional reduction in the benefits of planted pollinator habitats.

This is true even if there are organic farms interspersed within or adjacent to the herbicide-treated locations not only because of neonicotinoid dust overspray and drift, but also because of rainwater runoff and soil pathways. Although the contamination may not be strong enough to actually kill bees outright, it does weaken the viability of both the queen and the worker bees. The assumption is that this weakness may have led to the large winter kill-offs beekeepers have been complaining about, as well as reduced colony development.

Planting herbicide tolerant crops (photo from Wild Ones Wild for Monarchs)
“Regardless, the risk of exposure associated with honey bees foraging on wildflowers is consistently present in space, time, and across flowering forage species within this highly developed agricultural region.” (photo from Wild Ones Wild for Monarchs)

Since the likelihood that crop farmers will not stop using neonicotinoid-treated seed, the conclusion is to look for ways to protect the habitats from insecticide exposure. How to do that is the big question. I’d like to read your suggestions.

See also Wildflowers planted to aid bees may be crippling them.

Thank you Christian Nelson for bringing this research to my attention.

   Send article as PDF   

Comments

  1. Diane Olson Schmidt. LaceWing Gardening Services says

    August 18, 2016 at 9:01 pm

    There should be at least 100 or more feet from conventional farms and organic farms, small towns, (200-300ft rec.). Really, neonics should be banned in seed and in spray.
    Some rural residences and organic farms are resorting to using grow tunnels with filters to keep pesticides out. As far as farm border wildflower areas, about 200-300ft. surrounding the farming border and/or with some trees planted or some kind of barrier like an small earthen berm with trees planted might help or some kind of fencing, 6-8ft.ht. roll out might help reduce the insecticide exposure. I know these are not practical solutions, but the farmers who use the insecticides should also have to guard against drift and rain runoff in soil which drains into the lowest area.
    One idea from the companies who clean up hazardous waste areas plant tree barriers like Quaking Aspens, Willows to help sop up the neonics in the soil and rainwater. They can be planted along the edges with wildflower meadows in-between.

    Reply
    • Donna VanBuecken says

      August 19, 2016 at 12:26 pm

      Good thoughts, Diane. Tongue in cheek, mimicking current political rhetoric, we could also build a wall to keep out the aliens (invasive species).

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Signup button.

Recent Posts

  • OVER-THE-COUNTER NATIVE PLANT SALE MAY 21
  • WOFVA’s NATIVE PLANT SALE MAY 21
  • Recovering America’s Wildlife Act (RAWA)
  • Wisconsin Conservation Hall of Fame 2022 Inductees
  • Native Landscaping Design

Category Archives

  • Biodiversity
    • Monarchs
    • Pollinators
  • Birds
  • Climate Change
  • Events
  • Fire
  • Funding
  • Garden and Landscape Design
  • Heroes
  • Homestead
    • Recipe
  • Invasive Plants
  • Native plant garden design
  • Native Plants
  • Natural Landscaping
  • Prairie
  • Public Comment Opportunity
  • Railroad
  • The Sky
  • Wellbeing
  • Wetlands
  • Wildflowers
    • Trees & Shrubs
  • Wildlife
    • Wolves
  • Wisconsin
  • Women
  • Woodlands

Copyright 2005-2018
Donna VanBuecken